Slavoj Žižek - How to renounce your passion: A Hegelian lesson on the ethics of marriage

Let me begin with my central thesis. Far from providing the natural foundation of human lives, sexuality is the very terrain where humans detach themselves from nature ― the idea of sexual perversion or of a deadly sexual passion is totally foreign to non-human animals. Here, G.W.F. Hegel fails with regard to his own standards. He only considers how, in the process of culture, the natural substance of sexuality is cultivated, sublated, mediated: we humans no longer just make love for procreation; we get involved in a complex process of seduction and marriage by means of which sexuality becomes an expression of the spiritual bond between a man and a woman.

G.W.F. Hegel (1770-1831) formulated his theory of marriage over against two rival conceptions: the Kantian contract theory of marriage and the Romantic notion that prioritises the love attachment of the couple. Image:  The Wedding, by Leonid Solomatkin (De Agostini Picture Library / Getty Images)

However, what Hegel misses is how, once we are within the human condition, sexuality is not only transformed or civilised ― but, much more radically, is changed in its very substance. It is no longer the instinctual drive to reproduce, but a drive that gets thwarted as to its natural goal (reproduction) and thereby explodes into an infinite, properly meta-physical passion. The becoming-cultural of sexuality is thus not the becoming-cultural of nature, but the attempt to domesticate a properly unnatural excess of the metaphysical sexual passion.

This is the properly dialectical reversal of substance: the moment when the immediate substantial ("natural") starting point is not only acted upon, transformed, mediated/cultivated, but changed in its very substance. We not only work upon and thus transform nature; in a gesture of retroactive reversal, nature itself radically changes its "nature." (In an homologous way, once we enter the domain of legal civil society, the previous tribal order of honour and revenge is deprived of its nobility and appears as common criminality.)

This is why Catholics who insist that only sex for procreation is human while coupling for lust is animal totally miss the point and end up celebrating the animality of humans.

Read the full article here.

Reading Žižek – Where to Start?